Help!

I've found a tutorial on making a no-sew cushion cover, and am feeling inspired! Now, I need opinions.You've seen the picture of my front porch. The house is beige-y tan, trim is cream, and accents are a rusty-red kinda color. The new glider is green. And here are some fabrics from Jo-ann, both on sale:

(Waverly Sun-n-Shade Outdoor Fabric Paddock Shawl Persimmon)

(Waverly Sun-n-Shade Outdoor Fabric - Serene Stripe Cinnabar)

So, which one do I pick? Price is the same for each...